No shade, but Elena Kagan is a mess and needs to step aside from this climate lawsuit considering that she pushed BS climate science claims that all got yanked because of bias and conflict of interests š¬š¬š¬
Justice Alito has stepped aside from the Supreme Courtās major climate case, Suncor v. Boulder.
So there is another recusal question that deserves scrutiny: Justice Elena Kagan wrote the foreword to the federal judiciaryās Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence, specifically pointing judges toward climate-science litigation and falsely describing the manual as a ādispassionate guide.ā
The climate chapter was subsequently REMOVED by the Federal Judicial Center, and the National Academies admits questions about how it was produced warrant an independent review.
Under federal law, the test is whether a Justiceās impartiality āmight reasonably be questioned.ā
So what is Justice Kaganās answer? Recusal, or hypocrisy?