here's what I think they did with dots
this is mostly speculation, but I think they gave it an astra level model, but to balance this out, it runs at really high batch size or in periods of low demand or whatever, so basically giving people more intelligence at lower cost but at a delay, this is one of the reasons why the dot is so slow, this is going to be frustrating for people looking to use the dot to do realtime work
they don't make this clear enough, but you really still need to open chats for anything that is really focused work or which is large, they could have done a better job having the dot manage this for you, like allowing it to find chats for you, swap them in, merge them, etc... I think they did a bad job of this, the dot is really for personal assistant type work
which brings us to the first problem: permissions; they locked down what it can do, it can't send sensitive emails, its vm is useless because almost all relevant tasks require your passwords etc... but this makes it way worse than just using gpt-6-astra with computer use to do your tasks in real time, with standard chats, on your computer; this is disappointing
it's really important for these products to figure out secret management; it's sort of the most important part of the whole thing; you need an easy way to be able to delegate your permissions to it so that it can do work on your behalf, everything in the world is behind a password; so, if it can't manage secrets, it can't do much
also, the product is just strangely buggy, like messages don't load, they want you to send emails through the dot but told the dot not to send financial emails, so you want it to pull up the draft widget so you can send it but they removed the send button from the draft widget, presumably because they want to push you to send through the dot, which they decided can't send on your behalf
oh also, you can call the dot, it's just advanced voice mode packaged for ordinary people, but no thought was given as to making the voice match the appearance of the dot, or to making the voicemode connect quickly, so the experience leaves a lot to be desired; I don't even know what they get from making the voice mode connect slowly
it's a very strange product, it is very polished on the avatar, like incredibly polished, and then everywhere else, there's like no polish; maybe this is all about first mover advantage and they have really taken to heart that you have to be first, but first means the combination of application and model capability first, and the model has to be unhobbled, which this one is not
they really did nail the graphic design of dots, dots graphic design is really good, people are going to love it, or at least, their ordinary person personal assistant audience will love it, and that's really who its for, it's designed to make ai popular with people who don't use ai, it's not a dev tool really, even though as a ui/ux affordance, they also seem to want it to be a dev tool
but for it to really be a winner, it needs to be enterprise automation, because that's where the next big revenue spike is sitting, it's sitting in the hybrid of claude tag and computer use; so many enterprise tasks rely on this workflow, being able to nail it is a lot of tokens you can sell, you can get non-developers racking up claude code level bills for their companies
and you get the personal assistant; oh, and the personal assistant will need an additional layer on top and that is the ability to make phone calls on your behalf