He makes a good point.
Even if AI art didn’t often look “off” (and it won’t look weird for very long), it still feels like fundamentally a different thing. The time and experience and suffering and passion people put into their art is a huge part of the value we place on it.
An interesting experiment it to find an item you cherish that was hand made. Imagine how you’d feel if you discovered that it actually was NOT hand made. It was manufactured using automated machinery. The item maintains its utility and its aesthetics. So why are you sad about this revelation? Why does it feel less?
Hac intellegentiae artificialis aetate, urgens fit humanam artem ab iis distinguere, quae machinis efficiuntur. Ars enim et ea, quae machina ex innumeris alienis imaginibus statisticae ope computationis generare potest, ontologice, prius etiam quam aesthetice, inter se differunt. Algorithmis humani deest favilla. Quapropter Ecclesia cum artificibus et humani cultus institutis foedus renovare cupit: foedus scilicet ad humanum custodiendum.